Original Musical Numbers List
Act One
- Overture .... Orchestra
- You Can't Miss It .... Dan, Ruth & Ensemble
- It Wonders Me .... Katie
- Plenty of Pennsylvania .... Emma, Ezra, Another Young Miller & Ensemble
- Young and Foolish .... Peter, Katie
- Why Not Katie? .... Ezra and Men
- Young and Foolish (Reprise) .... Katie, Peter
- By Lantern Light .... Danced by Daniel Nagrin (Samuel Zook) and Ann Needham, with Sara Aman, Lucia Lambert, Tao Strong, Saint Amant, Crandall Diehl and Bob St. Clair
- It's a Helluva Way to Run a Love Affair .... Ruth
- This Is All Very New to Me .... Sung and danced by Hilda, Another Amishman, Levi & Ensemble
- Plain We Live .... Papa Yoder & Ensemble
- The Shunning .... The Company
Act Two
- How Do You Raise a Barn? .... Papa Yoder, Ezra, Emma, Samuel Zook & Ensemble
- Follow Your Heart .... Peter, Katie and Hilda
- City Mouse, Country Mouse .... Emma with Sarah, Esther, Mary, Rachel, Rebecca
- I'll Show Him! .... Hilda
- Carnival Ballet .... Hilda, Ezra and Company
- Carnival Ballet: On the Midway .... Mambo Joe, Scranton Sal, Swami, Sailor, Barkers
- Carnival Ballet: Dance Hall .... The Company
- Take Your Time and Take Your Pick .... Hilda, Dan, Ruth
- Plenty of Pennsylvania (Finale) .... The Entire Company
Additional Musical Numbers Lists
No songs listed for this production yet.