Original Musical Numbers List
Act One
- Can't Wait .... Young Josh, Mrs. Baskin, Billy, Kids and Parents
- Talk to Her .... Billy and Young Josh
- Carnival, The .... Company
- This Isn't Me .... Josh
- I Want to Go Home .... Josh
- The Time of Your Life .... The Kids
- Fun .... MacMillan, Josh and Company
- Dr. Deathstar .... The Deathstarettes
- Josh's Welcome .... Susan, Paul and Executives
- Here We Go Again .... Susan
- Stars, Stars, Stars .... Josh and Susan
- Tavern Foxtrot .... Paul and Company
- Cross the Line .... Josh, Kids and Company
Act Two
- It's Time .... Billy and The Kids
- Stop, Time .... Mrs. Baskin
- Happy Birthday, Josh .... The Kids
- Dancing All the Time .... Susan
- I Want to Know .... Young Josh
- Coffee, Black .... Josh, MacMillan, Miss Watson, Birnbaum, Barrett, Lipton, Executives and Staff
- The Real Thing .... Nick, Tom, Diane and Abigail
- One Special Man .... Susan
- When You're Big .... Josh
- Skateboard Romance .... The Kids
- I Want to Go Home (Reprise) .... Josh and Susan
- Stars, Stars, Stars (Reprise) .... Josh and Susan
Additional Musical Numbers Lists
These song lists document any changes that the production went through aside from the opening night song list.
Pre-Broadway
Act One
- Thirteen .... Mrs. Baskin, Kids and Parents
- Talk to Her .... Billy and Young Josh
- Carnival, The .... Company
- Big .... Josh and Mrs. Baskin
- I Want to Go Home .... Josh
- The Time of Your Life .... F.A.O. Clock
- Fun .... MacMillan, Josh and Company
- Dr. Deathstar .... The Deathstarettes
- I'll Think About It Later .... Susan, Paul and Executives
- Isn't It Magic? .... Susan and Josh
- Dish at the Dance .... Paul and Company
- Your Wish is Granted .... Cynthia Benson and Company
Act Two
- It's Time .... Billy and The Kids
- Stop, Time .... Mrs. Baskin
- Happy Birthday, Josh .... The Kids
- Dancing All the Time .... Susan
- I Want to Know .... Young Josh
- Coffee, Black .... Josh, MacMillan, Miss Watson, Birnbaum, Barrett, Lipton, Executives and Staff
- The Real Thing .... Nick, Tom, Diane and Abigal
- One Special Man .... Susan
- Big (Reprise) .... Josh and Billy
- Skateboard Romance .... The Kids
- I Want to Know .... Josh and Susan
- One Special Man (Reprise) .... Josh and Susan
- Finale .... Company